رد شبهة محاولة النبي – عليه الصلاة والسلام – الانتحار بعد فتور الوحي

أحمد عبد حسين العوايشه

Abstract



ملخص

يتناول البحث شبهةً ذكرها بعض أهل العلم – عفا الله عنهم – وهي قولهم: أن رسول الله – صلى الله عليه وسلم– همً بالانتحار بعد فتور الوحي عنه، ويظهر البحث ضعف إسناد هذه القصة، بعرض آراء أهل العلم فيها، ولما تحويه من مآخذ حديثية، مع ذكر من ضعفها من العلماء قديماً، وحديثاً. ويتناول البحث ضعف البلاغ الذي ساق الإمام الزهري هذه الرواية به، ويتناول البحث أيضاً المخالفات العقدية المترتبة على الأخذ بهذه الرواية ، وإنها وإن سلمت حديثياً فهي لم ولن تسلم عقدياً؛ لما تحويه من طعن في مقام النبوة.

 

Against the Allegation that the Prophet Intended to kill Himself during the Period in Which There Was a Break of Revelation

 

Ahmed Abid Husien Al-Awaisheh

 

Abstract

This research discusses one of the allegations mentioned by scholars, namely the claim that the prophet intended to kill himself during the period in which there was a break of revelation. The research shows the weakness of this narration in the light of scholars' views because of some criticism that the narration includes from a hadith perspective. The research mentions those who rejected the narration in question whether in modern time or before, the research also shows the doctrinal criticisms of this narration which is considered against the prophet's message.

Keywords: Infallibility, Suicide, Allegations, Revelation, AL-Zuhri .

 

Keywords


العصمة ؛ الانتحار؛ شبهات ؛ الوحي؛ الزهري

References


References:

Al-Albani, M. (W.D). Silsilat al-ahadith al-da'ifa wa al- mawdu'a (1st ed), Knowledge house, Riyadh.

Al-Albani, Muhammad Nasir al-Diyn, (W.D). Difa' 'an al- hadith, Al - Khafiqayn Foundation.

Al-Asfahani, Hussein Bin Mohammed (W.D). Al- mufradat fi gharib al- qur'an, Library nizar mustafa al- baz.

Al-'ashkar, O. (1989). Al- rusul wa al- risalat (4th ed), Al-nafa'is house.

Al-'askari, Hassan Bin Abd Allah (W.D). Al-furuq al- lughawiyyah, (Investigation: Mohammed bin ibrahim), House of science and culture for publication and distribution.

Al-'asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali bin Hajar, (1379). Fath al-bari sharh sahih al-bukhari, Beirut : Knowledge house .

Al–'aswad, S. (2011). Blaghat al- 'imam al- zuhri wa 'idragatuhu fi sahih al- bukhari, Islamic University, 19 (2), p:575- 626.

Al-Bukhari, M. (1422). Sahih al-bukhari(1st ed), Tawq al-Najat House.

Al-Buti, M. (2003). Fiqh al- sirah al- nabawiyyah(11th ed), Contemporary thought house, Beirut: Thought house.

Al-Dhahabi, Mohammed Bin Ahmed (1963). Mizan al-i'tidal fi naqd al-rijal(1st ed), Knowledge house printing and publishing.

Al-Dhahabi, Mohammed bin Ahmed bin 'uthman, (1985). Siyar a'lam al nubala' (3rd ed), Al-risalah printing house, (Investigation: Shu'aib al- arna'ut and others.

Al-Jawhari, Ismail Bin Hammad. (W.D). Al- sihaah taj al-lughah wa sihah al-'arabiya (4th ed), (Investigation: Ahmed abd al- ghafoor), Beirut : House of science for millions,.

Al-Matrafi, A. (1402). Ayat 'itab al – mustafa fi daw' al- ismah wa al- ijtihad (1st ed).

Al-Mubarakfuri, S. (W.D). Al- rahiq al- makhtum, Nizar Library, Mustafa Al-Baz House.

Al-Nawawi, Yahya Bin Sharaf, (1985). Al- taqriyb wa al- taysyr (1st ed), Arabic book house.

Al-Razi, Mohammed Bin Abi Bakr, (2001). Mokhtar al-sihah (2nd ed), Cultural Books Foundation.

Al-Razi, Mohammed Bin Omar ,(1420). Mafatih al- ghayb (3rd ed), Beirut: Arab heritage revival house,.

Al-Tabari, Mohammed bin Jarir(W.D). Gami' al- bayan fi tafsir al- qur'an( 1st ed).

Al-Tirmidi, Mohammed bin 'isa (W.D). Gami' al-tirmidi, (Investigation: Muhammad nasir al-din al-albani), Ideas international house.

Bodley, R. (W.D). The prophet (Muhammad's life), (Translated by: Mohamed Faraj and Abd al-Hamid al- Sahar), Egypt library.

Hamdan, N. (W.D). Al- rasul fi kitabat al- mustashriqin, The publications of the muslim world League.

Ibn 'atiya, Abd Al- Haq bin Ghalib al- Andalusi, (2001). Al- muharar al- wagiz fi tafsir al- kitab Al- 'aziz(1st ed), (Investigation: Abd al- salam abd al - shafi mohammed), Scientific book house.

Ibn faris, Abu al-Hussein, (2008). Mu'jam maqayis al- lughah, Al- Hadith house, Cairo, without edition.

Ibn Hajar, Ahmed bin Ali, (1999). Taqriyb al- tahdhib(1st ed), (Investigation: 'Adel morshed), Message foundation

Ibn hanbal, Ahmad, (2001). Al- musnad(1st ed), (Investigation: Sho'aib al- arna'ut), Al-risala foundation.

Ibn hazm, Ali Bin Ahmed al- Andalusi, (1428). AL–fisal fi al-milal wa al- ahwa' wa al- nihal (3rd ed), Beirut: Scientific book house,.

Ibn katheer, Isma'il, (2010). Al- bidayah wa nihayah(1st ed), Cairo: Ibn al-jawzi house,.

Ibn Majah, Muhammad Bin Yazid al-Gharnawi (W.D). Sunan ibn majah (1sted), (Investigation: Muhammad nasir al-Din al-Albani), Knowledge library for publishing and distribution.

Ibn taymiyah, Ahmed Bin Abd al- Halim, (2000). Majmu' al- fatawa(2nd ed), Al-wafa house and Ibn hazm house.

Ibn taymiyah, Ahmed bin Abd al- Halim (W.D). Minhag al- sunna(1st ed), (Investigation: Mohammad rashad salem), Cordoba foundation.

Judge 'iyad, Abu Al-Fadl Al-Yahsubi. (W.D). Al-shifa bi t'rif huquq al- mustafa, Beirut: Scientific book house.

Muslim, Ibn Al- Hajjaj Al- Nisabouri (W.D). Sahih muslim, (Investigation: Mohamed fo'ad abd al- baqi), Beirut: Arab heritage revival house , ,.

Rida, M. (1406). Al- wahi al- muhammadi (2nd ed). 'izz al-din foundation for printing.

Sakhawi, Mohammed bin Abd al- Rahman, (2001). Fath al-mughiyth sharh alfiyyat alhadith, Beirut: Scientific Book House, .

Suyuti, Abd al- Rahman bin Abi Bakr (W.D). Al- khasa'is al- qubra, Beirut :Scientific book house .

Suyuti, Abd Al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr (W.D). Tadrib al- rawi, Tayba House.

Wali Allah al- dahlawi, Ahmed bin Abd al- Rahiym, (2005).Hujat Allah al- baligha (1st ed), (Investigation :A l-sayd sabiq), Beirut: Generation house.

The hadith sent is the saying of the ta'ibi: he said, "Pray and peace, even though he did not meet the Messenger of Allah( peace be upon him) and peace be upon him."See: Fath al-Mughaith, previous reference, c1 p. 152

The dilemma altogether: in the terminology: it is (the fallen of it) i.e. of his attribution (two onwards) i.e. with a straight . See: Fath al-Mughaith, previous reference, C1 p. 176.

Al-Albanian, Muhammad Nasser al-Din (T:1420), defending the Prophet's Hadith and Biography, without edition or history.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.35682/197

Published by
MUTAH UNIVERSITY